Nutter Butter Banana Cream Trifle Recipe

I absolutely adore sharing this Nutter Butter Banana Cream Trifle Recipe with friends and family because it combines some of my favorite flavors into one irresistible, creamy dessert. The soft layers of banana-flavored pudding perfectly complement the crunchy, peanut buttery Nutter Butter cookies and fresh banana slices, making each bite a delightful surprise. I find that this trifle is not only delicious but also fun to assemble and always a showstopper when I bring it to gatherings.

Why You'll Love This Nutter Butter Banana Cream Trifle Recipe

One of the first reasons I fall head over heels for this recipe is its incredible flavor profile. The creamy banana pudding blends beautifully with the rich peanut butter taste of Nutter Butter cookies, while the fresh bananas add a natural sweetness and a refreshing texture contrast. It’s like a peanut butter-and-banana sandwich transformed into the ultimate indulgent dessert.

Another reason I’m so enthusiastic about this recipe is how easy it is to put together. I don’t consider myself a professional baker, so any dessert that requires no baking and comes together in about 15 minutes is a winner in my book. Plus, with just a handful of simple ingredients, it’s something I can whip up quickly for last-minute occasions or casual family dinners.

Finally, this Nutter Butter Banana Cream Trifle Recipe really stands out because it looks gorgeous when layered in a glass trifle bowl. When I serve it, guests get to see all those vibrant banana slices and cookie layers peeking through, which always draws compliments before they've even taken a bite! Whether it’s a holiday dessert, a potluck feature, or a festive weekend treat, this recipe never disappoints.

Ingredients You'll Need

I love how straightforward this recipe is when it comes to ingredients—all of them play an important role in creating the flavors and textures I adore. From the creamy banana pudding to the crunchy Nutter Butter cookies and fresh bananas, every element is simple but essential for achieving that perfect balance in the trifle.

• Whole milk: Provides a creamy base that thickens perfectly when combined with banana pudding.
• Instant banana cream pudding mix: Adds that rich banana flavor and a silky texture.
• Whipped topping: Lightens the pudding and gives the trifle a fluffy, airy finish.
• Nutter Butter cookies: The star ingredient that adds crunch and signature peanut butter flavor.
• Fresh bananas: Bring natural sweetness and a fresh, fruity layer that balances the dessert.
• Creamy peanut butter: Just warmed up to drizzle on top for added richness and indulgence.

Directions

Step 1: In a large bowl, whisk together the cold whole milk and the instant banana cream pudding mix for about 3 minutes until the mixture thickens significantly. Then, gently fold in half of the whipped topping (4 ounces) until smooth and creamy. Set this luscious banana cream mixture aside.

Step 2: Arrange 9 to 10 Nutter Butter cookies in a single layer across the bottom of your trifle bowl. This cookie base will soak up the pudding, so spreading them evenly is key for consistent texture.

Step 3: Layer about half of your fresh banana slices evenly on top of the cookies, making sure you cover the entire surface. Then, pour half of your prepared banana cream pudding over the bananas, spreading it out carefully. I like to keep the edges neat so that when you look at the bowl, the layers are beautifully visible.

Step 4: Repeat this layering process: cookies, bananas, and pudding. Finally, finish with another layer of cookies and bananas. Top it all off with the remaining whipped topping to create a fluffy cap.

Step 5: Cover your trifle bowl lightly with plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least 4 hours, or ideally overnight. This resting time is so important because it allows the cookies to soften, melding all the flavors together into a creamy, dreamy texture.

Step 6: Just before serving, crumble a few extra Nutter Butter cookies on top for a delightful crunch. Warm the peanut butter in the microwave for 15-30 seconds until it’s drizzly, then generously drizzle it over the top. Scoop out large spoonfuls and watch your guests’ eyes light up!

Servings and Timing

This Nutter Butter Banana Cream Trifle Recipe makes about 12 generous servings, which is perfect for sharing with a crowd or making sure everyone gets seconds. The prep time is impressively quick at around 15 minutes, since it requires no baking. There’s no cook time involved either, but be sure to refrigerate the dessert for at least 4 hours to let the layers meld beautifully. The total time, including chilling, comes to roughly 4 hours and 15 minutes—giving you plenty of opportunity to prepare ahead of any event.

How to Serve This Nutter Butter Banana Cream Trifle Recipe

I love serving this trifle chilled because the cold temperature really enhances the smooth banana cream and keeps the cookie layers pleasantly soft but still slightly textured. It’s such a refreshing dessert especially after a rich meal, making it a perfect end to holiday dinners or casual Sunday feasts with family and friends.

For presentation, I always recommend serving this trifle in a clear glass bowl or individual glass parfait dishes so the beautiful layers show through. Garnishing with extra banana slices, some chopped roasted peanuts, or even a small sprig of mint adds an elegant touch and extra texture that guests appreciate.

When it comes to what to drink alongside, I find this dessert pairs wonderfully with a lightly sweet white wine like a Riesling or with a sparkling lemonade for a non-alcoholic option. On warmer days, I sometimes opt for iced tea with a hint of lemon to cut through the sweetness. This dish is incredibly versatile and shines at both casual get-togethers and festive holiday celebrations.

Variations

I really enjoy experimenting with this Nutter Butter Banana Cream Trifle Recipe, so I’ve tried a few twists that work beautifully. For example, if you want a more intense peanut butter flavor, feel free to mix a little peanut butter into the banana pudding itself before layering. It gives an extra punch that peanut butter lovers will adore.

If you or your guests have dietary restrictions, you can make this trifle gluten-free by swapping the Nutter Butter cookies for gluten-free peanut butter sandwich cookies. For a vegan twist, use a dairy-free banana pudding mix, coconut milk, and a plant-based whipped topping. I’ve found that using ripe plantains instead of bananas also adds an interesting flavor variation without losing that creamy fruit element.

Another fun variation is to add layers of crushed chocolate or caramel sauce between the pudding and cookies for an even richer dessert. While the traditional recipe is no-bake, if you’re feeling fancy, you can toast the sliced bananas lightly in a pan with a sprinkle of brown sugar to caramelize them before layering. It creates a deeper flavor that pairs so well with the peanut butter notes.

Storage and Reheating

Storing Leftovers

Leftover trifle can be stored easily by covering it tightly with plastic wrap or transferring to an airtight container. I recommend keeping it refrigerated, where it will stay fresh for up to 3 days. Since the dessert contains whipped topping and fresh bananas, it’s best enjoyed within that time frame to maintain taste and texture.

Freezing

Because this trifle contains delicate whipped topping and fresh fruit, freezing isn’t ideal. I wouldn’t recommend freezing this dessert as it can compromise the texture of the pudding and cause the fruit to become mushy. If you have leftovers, sticking to refrigeration is your best bet for preserving quality.

Reheating

This dessert is meant to be served chilled, so reheating is not necessary or recommended. If anything, you can take the trifle out of the fridge a few minutes before serving to let it warm slightly to room temperature for a softer experience, but keeping it cold really highlights the flavors best.

FAQs

Can I use homemade banana pudding instead of instant mix?

Absolutely! If you prefer homemade banana pudding, feel free to prepare your favorite recipe and use it as a substitute. Just make sure it’s fully cooled before assembling the trifle so the layers hold up nicely.

What can I use if I don’t have Nutter Butter cookies?

If Nutter Butters are hard to find, peanut butter sandwich cookies or even peanut butter-flavored graham crackers can work well as a substitute, though the signature shape of Nutter Butters adds to the fun presentation.

How ripe should the bananas be?

I like using ripe but firm bananas—ones that are yellow with a few brown spots. They’re sweet and flavorful without being too mushy, so they hold their shape well within the trifle layers.

Can I prepare this trifle a day in advance?

Yes! In fact, I highly recommend preparing it the day before serving. The extra time in the fridge allows the cookies to soften perfectly and the flavors to meld into such a delicious harmony.

Is this recipe suitable for kids?

Definitely! This dessert is a family favorite and the creamy banana and peanut butter flavors usually appeal to children. Just be mindful of any peanut allergies if serving to a group.

Conclusion

If you’re looking for a dessert that’s quick to prepare, full of comforting flavors, and always gets rave reviews, I can’t recommend this Nutter Butter Banana Cream Trifle Recipe enough. It’s one of my go-to treats whenever I want to impress without stress, and I truly hope you enjoy making and sharing it as much as I do!

Print